
**spoilers ahead**
Angel is often praised as the darkest of
Joss Whedon's shows, not that Buffy was all sunniness or that Firefly, or Dollhouse themselves have a particularly optimistic view of human nature or human institutions. Angel was primarily about a man who was forced to deal with the consequences of his past and make amends, it was a story of the search for redemption, but that struggle was never an easy one. Angel from Season 1 to 5 is the
Joss Whedon's attempt life allegory at it's starkest and most earth bound, it had something to do with the city LA, and it had something to do with the people the man surrounded himself with, but of course like Buffy, life was often a struggle by itself without demons and vampires to deal with. Angel beat Buffy in it's central villain (s) (although Buffy had it's share of well written and played ones), law firm Wolfram and Hart, another tie into the real world and it's moral gray areas. Ultimately I prefer Buffy just for the quality of it's particular episodes (
eps like The Body, Restless and Once More with Feeling are among the greatest television ever), but as a whole Angel is just as compelling as it's father show, it's a portrait of people creating a surrogate family to hold off the world, a show about the burden of responsibility, about the moral ambiguity that pervades
dispite any clear moral code, and it never hurt that in a moments notice Angel(or Buffy for that matter) could stop at notice of the sound of either of their names, but it was too the credit of this show that it developed on it's own, while expanded on
Whedon's own philosophical fascinations.
5.
Birthday On Buffy
Cordelila Chase was pretty much a source of comic relief for 2 seasons (she was merely Buffy's rival in the first season), and although she had a few grace moments (her relationship with
Xander being the biggest), it wasn't until Angel that she became a truly compelling character nearly on par with Angel himself. Specifically it was the third season when the employees of Angel Investigations really bounded together to become a surrogate family, and with the birth of Connor,
Cordelila got to play surrogate mother. Two seasons of visions had changed her, and although the show had commented on that change up until that point and her developing relationship with Angel, Surprise was where Cordelia actually got to choose between those two lives, the spoiled rich girl/superstar actress vs a sacrificial hero against the forces of evil. She gets her It's a Wonderful Life moment with an alternate future where she never met up with Angel in the shows pilot episode. You can praise
alot here, Cordy's ghost conversations with people who can't even see her, the continual surrogate family vibe regarding Connor, her conversations with vision guide Skip in a mall of all places, and then the Choice. In a simple and yet non-sentimental way Surprise not only shows us the degree to which Cordelia had matured but also how her presence has served as a humanizing factor for Angel. Even though things will get
alot worse before they ever get better for them all, Cordelia's demon accession is not only a wide grin moment, but the best touch off ending for this character who reached her peak here (although Season 5's You're Welcome comes close as well).
4.
Are You Now or Have You Ever Been - Season 2 was where Angel really became it's own show(despite continually sharing it's central character's mythology with Buffy) and this
ep was a bold declaration of the series ambitions. It expands on the central themes of the series , while working as a standalone tale. It is unquestionably the best of the Angel flashback episodes, and part of the reason is that it was the first to really take the viewer out of the 18
th and 19
th century's, which the previous
Angelus/Angel flashbacks had been placed. It's a ghost story, and a mid century period piece with lots of wonderfully written moments about 1950's LA, scenes that touch on Hollywood, the Red scare, and race relations. The central baddie is one of the most terrifying things the series would ever come up with, and the ultimate horror lies in how the villain draws on the characters fears and anxieties (and listen to that voice of the actor). It's a gorgeous work that ultimately affirms Angel's desire to stand up to the evils of the world be they supernatural or more everyday.
3.
Through the Looking Glass - This is my favorite episode of the
Pillia arc although I could have selected There's No Place Like
Plrtz Glrb. The
Pillia arc is one of the great achievements in televised sci
fi, at once a remarkable departure for this series, and yet unmistakably of it. It's tonally speaking one of the best things
Joss Whedon and David
Greenwalt ever did in their careers. It's a fairy tale but in the true traditions of those European stories, there are mirror or opposite reflections to everything. Humans are slaves, or "cows", the
pillians heart is in their ass, their sun doesn't hurt Angel but it does turn him into demon incarnate when angered. Most perversely this universes "hero" is a tall exotic human demon hybrid who is regarded by the demons as grotesque, and yet who is about every human woman's dream. Plus
Cordilla is queen!!. Of course she's a puppet queen and religion is used to enslave and control the
populace. But the most haunting aspect of this episode is the beauty and beast A plot regarding Angel and Fred, as Angel vows never to return to LA(or our dimension) after
Gunn and Wesley witness his demonic self and Fred plays his protector (and he plays that role vise
versa when in human form), the shot that gives me pause is the one where the beast looks at his reflection in a pool of water and haunted by what he sees transforms into his human self. Speaking of reflections Angel sees his hair in a mirror and he wonders it is so spiky. On top of everything this
ep is just plain funny.
2.
Waiting in the Wings - This is one of the great romantic works in American television,. Angel Investigations goes to the Ballet, ot's basically a 42 minute
version of the Red Shoes where art and life ultimately and boldly reflect each other. Cordy and Angel very nearly consummate their relationship (and it's sexy as f*$K) as they play out the roles that the
spirts of past had (note the similarity between Buffy's "I Only Have Eyes for You" which also had Angel as the spirit vessel), and
Gunn and Fred actually begin their romance with a kiss in the heat of battle. This is
Joss Whedon's only directing credit on my list and he wrote it as well, and it's one of his finest. Stylistically it's one's of his most lyrical works, with gorgeous dolly's, pans and crane shots. It's also a fascinating cautionary tale of the cost blind love can give, reflected in the very supernatural forces that create the massive backstage labyrinth, itself serving as a subtle visual evocation of the
villains obsession. In her first major film or television appearance Summer
Gulu plays the star ballerina, trapped in time with the rest of the troupe, an image of seeming perfection for the
villain. She has performed the same dance for over a century, and is still aware of every single pain in serving as the object of desire (her late
ep monologue is powerfully conveyed by
Gulu). In the end though the heart of Waiting in the Wings is with Wesley as he loses his own game of love, and
Whedon usual empathic eye comes into play in executing the parallel between him and
Cristoff, of course where one man fights against the love of two others, this man valiantly but sadly accepts his own place as friend and co worker in this episodes haunting final shot.
1.
Not Fade Away - My favorite
ep is ultimately my
fav due to it's ending, the most powerful in American television. No by the close, Angel is not a greater series then Deadwood or the Wire, or recent
fav Breaking Bad, but if it's going to be remembered for anything it really should be that ending. Of course without the rest of the series it doesn't really carry the same weight. That's not to say that the rest of the
ep is less then excellent it's just it's almost like Angel's greatest hits, with
Whedon's and director/ writer Jeffery Bell closing out some of the stories and in their own way giving their final nods to the
Buffyverse as a whole. But honestly outside of the ending, I would rank the death of Lindsey,
noir style, at the hands of Lorne with two bullets in the chest, itself a shout out to the original
version of the show as a detective series. It was fitting as Lindsey was one of the first characters on Angel, with his arc standing out front and center in
Whedon's thematic focus with the series. It makes sense that Angel would make his move by taking him out as he was in many ways his mirror reflection. Then there is Wesley's death and boy what a dozy as
Illeryia changed into Fred's form and you realize in this moment that she's not lying, she is really grieving for him even if she doesn't love him. Not Fade Away delivers the action goods as well, with the creators writing up a Godfather baptism style massacre on the Circle of Black
Thorne, with no chance to survive the fall out for the characters. Angels confrontation with Hamilton brought on the geek boy sweetness as Hamilton gave away the source of his strength. Bell and
Whedon provide the viewer with a lyrical interlude prior to the action where all the players (Lindsey included) indulges themselves prior to "
cowboying up",
Gunn goes back to his old neighborhood, Lorne does his nightclub act, Spike reads his poetry to a receptive crown praise
more then a 100 years in the making, Wesley takes care of
Illyeria and Angel has a chat with his son. But it's that ending that sticks out, the cumulative images of
Whedon's central concerns on this series(and Buffy), that you fight against the evil of the world not cause you're going to win but because it defines who you are. Redemption or not when Angel goes out with Spike,
Gunn and
Illeria, even if they they live or they die, that brutal final image and call to arms reminds you amends is an uphill battle for everybody. It's a bleak yet life affirming way to close this important work of American television.